My 4-year-old child is undeniably talented, evident from his early mastery of multiplication tables. There’s a possibility that he might fall within the autism spectrum, have ADHD, and/or experience sensory challenges, although distinguishing these from typical 4-year-old behaviors can be challenging. My primary concern, however, revolves around avoiding an information echo chamber. To delve deeper into my son’s giftedness and potential neurodiversity, I’ve engaged with Facebook groups catering to “twice-exceptional” (2e) and gifted children, consulted with a resource specialist, and transitioned him to a specialized preschool tailored for gifted students, with plans to continue till 1st grade. Initially, these endeavors seemed beneficial, offering a sense of camaraderie and access to valuable resources shared by parents facing similar challenges.
Yet, recent apprehensions have surfaced regarding the potential infiltration of pseudoscience within these circles due to the insular nature of shared information and service providers. While these individuals are not opposed to vaccination, discussions often veer towards topics like primitive reflexes, auditory processing disorders, school refusal labeled as a disorder, oppositional defiant disorder, and a strong inclination towards homeschooling as the sole viable option for 2e students. Distinguishing between valid but lesser-known concepts and unfounded trends within this community poses a dilemma, exacerbated by the proliferation of seemingly credible sources online. How can I discern between genuine approaches, possibly overlooked by the mainstream, and unfounded beliefs gaining traction without empirical validation? My attempts at independent research yield conflicting results, with both scientifically-backed and dubious information presented convincingly. Assistance is appreciated!
—Gifted and Troubled
Dear Gifted and Troubled,
Maintain a personalized approach focused on your child’s unique needs, distinct from the perceived requirements of an “average” or conventionally developing child, or the consensus within a specific parental cohort. The behaviors you observe may indicate early signs warranting targeted interventions, or they could simply reflect the individuality of a young child evolving along their growth trajectory. Vigilantly monitor your child’s development, recognizing his requirements, strengths, coping mechanisms, and growth trajectory.
At the age of four, determining the optimal learning environment and conditions for your child is premature. Avoid prematurely concluding that homeschooling is the exclusive educational avenue suitable for your child. Educational institutions vary significantly in their support for diverse learning styles. Refrain from rigidly adhering to a singular mindset, assuming that a particular label such as “2E” mandates a universal educational or holistic approach.
Community support is invaluable for parents of neurodivergent children. However, exercise caution towards individuals advocating a singular, definitive environment or approach as the ultimate solution for children with specific needs. Remember, the most vocal individuals may not always possess the most accurate insights, and their children’s experiences may not mirror your own. No one comprehends your child as you do. Dedicate your focus to understanding your son’s learning style comprehensively and collaboratively engage with trusted professionals to tailor interventions that nurture his growth and well-being.
—Nicole
More Advice From Slate
My mother exhibits strictness regarding my clothing choices, not primarily driven by modesty concerns but influenced by our Indian and Catholic background, emphasizing modest attire. While I respect this aspect, my struggle lies in her reluctance to embrace my personal style preferences divergent from hers. Despite acknowledging and respecting her opinions on clothing length, I encounter resistance when expressing my unique fashion sense during shopping trips.