My nearly 4-year-old daughter, “Z,” adamantly refuses to heed my instructions as a father. She shows a slight inclination to listen to her mother, but even that cooperation seems to be dwindling.
Interestingly, Z exhibits angelic behavior at preschool, where she dutifully follows her teachers’ guidance and garners favor among the staff. Similarly, in her swim class and gymnastics sessions, she complies with her coaches’ instructions. However, outside these structured environments, Z’s compliance wanes significantly. It’s as if she selectively tunes us out, excelling in ignoring our requests with remarkable skill. Whether it’s a simple task or leaving a public place like the park, the situation often escalates to a point where she has to be carried to the car amid protests. Moreover, bedtime has transformed into a nightly ordeal, stretching for hours before she settles down.
Her repertoire of bedtime avoidance tactics is extensive—ranging from delaying bath time by engaging in puzzles to endless requests for different books or additional stories, multiple bathroom trips, or outright resistance to the bedtime routine. This ongoing struggle leaves both my wife and me feeling drained, frustrated, and at odds with each other. It has reached a point where I, especially, hesitate to take Z out due to the anticipation of her noncompliance and ensuing tantrums. Hence, my primary concern is how to cultivate a level of responsiveness from Z towards us, her parents, akin to the respect she shows other authority figures in her life. While I understand that children may not always be compliant, this situation demands improvement.
—Challenges with Z
Dear Challenges with Z,
Parenting expert Janet Lansbury offers valuable insight into the dynamics of parent-child interactions. She highlights the importance of accurately articulating the issue at hand, distinguishing between a child’s failure to listen and their reluctance to obey or cooperate. Acknowledging this distinction can foster a deeper understanding of the underlying struggle for parental authority rather than a mere communication lapse. The disparity in Z’s behavior between home and external settings is a common phenomenon observed in preschoolers. The structured routines and peer influence in educational environments often prompt children to conform to rules and expectations.
Children may reserve their noncompliant behavior for home environments where they feel more comfortable testing boundaries and asserting independence after a day of conforming to external regulations. At Z’s age, self-awareness might not be fully developed, but the underlying emotions and reactions are likely present. To address this, consider reducing Z’s extracurricular commitments to minimize situations requiring her compliance. Creating a more relaxed and unstructured environment at home can alleviate the need for constant adherence to instructions, reducing potential conflicts.
A similar approach can be applied to bedtime routines by streamlining activities to minimize transitions and potential sources of resistance. While establishing rituals is crucial, excessive components can prolong the process, leading to frustration. By simplifying the bedtime routine, you can create a more conducive environment for Z to transition smoothly into sleep.
Although the prospect of spending more time at home with Z may initially seem daunting, recalibrating your approach to prioritize quality over quantity can yield positive outcomes. By fostering a nurturing and understanding environment that aligns with Z’s emotional needs, you may witness a gradual improvement in her responsiveness and cooperation.
Seeking Parenting Guidance or Family Advice?
Submit your inquiries to Care and Feeding here . Your submissions remain anonymous and may be edited for publication.
Dear Care and Feeding,
Each year, I receive a Christmas card from a high school friend with whom I am not particularly close. While I appreciate family photos, their tradition of featuring their children in diapers surrounded by white Christmas lights has become unsettling. As the boys have grown older, the imagery feels inappropriate, with the eldest now 8 years old. Sending these photos to a wide audience raises concerns about consent and boundaries. Am I overreacting, or should I address this discomfort?
—Questionable Christmas Cards
Dear Questionable Christmas Cards,
Your unease regarding the evolving nature of the Christmas card tradition is valid. As children grow older, certain practices may become outdated or potentially inappropriate, necessitating a reassessment of the content shared with a broader audience. While the intention behind the photos may be lighthearted, considering the children’s ages and the evolving societal norms is crucial in maintaining a respectful and considerate approach to holiday greetings.
Addressing your concerns with tact and sensitivity can help navigate this delicate situation. Engaging in a candid conversation with your friend, expressing your discomfort with the imagery while acknowledging the intention behind the tradition, may provide clarity and potentially lead to a more suitable alternative for future cards. Emphasizing the importance of respecting the children’s privacy and autonomy as they grow older can foster a deeper understanding of boundaries and consent in the context of family traditions.
Stay Updated on Care and Feeding
· Missed previous columns this week? Read them here .
· Join the discussion in the Slate Parenting Facebook group to share your thoughts on this column!
Dear Care and Feeding,
My older sister faced unexpected pregnancies that led her to drop out of school and rely on our parents for support. Despite recommendations from educators and healthcare providers, she has chosen not to medicate her son, who struggles with severe ADHD. Consequently, his behavior often mirrors that of a hyperactive young child, posing challenges during family outings and gatherings. As I navigate my own pregnancy and seek to support my niece and nephew, I find myself overwhelmed by the demands of managing my nephew’s behavior.
While my niece is well-behaved and enjoys spending time with her friends, my nephew’s energy levels and impulsive actions require constant supervision and accommodation. My sister perceives my preference for spending time with my niece as favoritism, leading to tensions within the family. Balancing my responsibilities as an aunt and soon-to-be parent with the complexities of managing my nephew’s condition has become increasingly challenging. How can I address these familial dynamics and support both my niece and nephew effectively?
—Navigating Family Dynamics
Dear Navigating Family Dynamics,
Your family dynamics present a complex interplay of challenges, requiring a delicate balance of empathy, understanding, and proactive communication. While the disparities in your niece and nephew’s behaviors may pose distinct challenges, fostering a supportive and inclusive environment for both children is paramount.
Acknowledging the unique needs of each child and the impact of your nephew’s ADHD on family interactions is crucial in navigating these dynamics effectively. Initiating open and honest conversations with your sister about your concerns and the importance of addressing your nephew’s condition can pave the way for constructive dialogue and potential solutions. Emphasizing the significance of seeking professional guidance and exploring treatment options for your nephew’s ADHD can offer valuable support and resources for managing his symptoms.
An inclusive and understanding family dynamic can be fostered by making an effort to provide both children with chances to participate in meaningful activities that suit their interests and requirements. By fostering a supportive and compassionate environment that accommodates the diverse needs of each child, you can navigate these familial challenges with empathy and resilience.
—Rebecca
Additional Insights From Slate
Even though I’m not a smoker, I have a serious attraction to female smokers. In case someone, ideally a beautiful woman, is searching for a cigarette, I make it a point to have a pack on hand at all times. It seems like my strategy was successful; I was able to sell a few smokes to a lonely woman, and now we’re starting to form a relationship—I hope it’s more than just a friendship at this point. But when she finds out I don’t smoke, she’ll ask why I have smokes on hand. How can I answer this question in a way that won’t make her run away?