Debating Unconventional Baby Names: Father-to-Be Objects to ‘Hippie’ Name for Daughter

February 28, 2024

A man recently shared his dilemma on Reddit where he faces a significant decision under a tight time constraint. His wife is due to give birth to a baby girl in just two days, yet they have not finalized a name for her. The expectant father, referred to as the OP, disclosed on the “Am I The A—hole? (AITA?)” subreddit that they have explored “hundreds if not thousands” of names but hold contrasting preferences that are causing a deadlock in their decision-making process.

What Does He Prefer?

Adobe Stock Image by Benjamin Clapp

The OP leans towards more “classic” names such as Elizabeth, Emily, Natasha, Hannah, Katherine, Francesca, Matilda, Annabelle, Isabelle, Vivienne, Sadie, and Amelia. He favors names that are conventional and mainstream. Conversely, his wife finds these names “boring” or “old-fashioned.”

What Does She Prefer?

Adobe Stock Image by Gajus

On the other hand, the OP’s wife is inclined towards names that are more “unique” and what he describes as “hippy.” She has suggested names like Skye, Indie, River, Ocean, Seraphina, Atlas, Clove, Dove, Asteria, Lennox, Ember, and Wynter. The OP believes that a more common name would better suit their daughter rather than one that sounds invented for the sake of uniqueness.

Reddit’s Response

Photo Illustration by Rafael Henrique/SOPA Images/LightRocket via Getty Images

The Reddit community empathizes with the OP’s predicament and acknowledges the need for compromise in their decision. Suggestions range from nature-inspired names like Rose, Fern, Violet, Lily, and Summer to more traditional options such as Hazel, Thelma, Naomi, Eliza, Eden, Evangeline, Daisy, Holly, Chloe, Daphne, Violet, and Ivy. The name “Seraphina” has also garnered support for its classic appeal despite initial reservations.

As the due date approaches, Redditors advise the couple to create a shortlist of names that align with each other’s preferences to facilitate the decision-making process. By finding a middle ground between classic and unique names, they can navigate this challenging situation with mutual understanding and respect.

Exploring various name options can lead to a harmonious resolution as they prepare to welcome their daughter in March.

Close
Your custom text © Copyright 2024. All rights reserved.
Close