Whenever I encounter headlines or memes urging us to refrain from shouting at our children, I feel the urge to respond in a similar manner.
I recently came across an article in the Washington Post titled “How (and why) to stop yelling at your kids.” The piece promotes the gentle parenting approach, using neuroscience to emphasize the detrimental effects of yelling on children. This serves as a frustrating illustration of how parenting advice often overlooks crucial nuances, leading to increased feelings of guilt and shame among parents.
On the same day that this anti-yelling article was published, I found myself engaged in what could be described as a yelling match with my 9-year-old. Positioned at opposite ends of the stairs, we stubbornly held our ground, exchanging heated words. Despite my vocal escalation, I couldn’t help but acknowledge that we were not making any progress. However, in my exhausted state of mind at 7:45 pm on a Tuesday, I found it challenging to break free from this cycle. Fortunately, my husband intervened, allowing us to defuse the situation and move forward with our family evening.
In the past, I would have been consumed by self-criticism over such an incident. However, after years of working as a “parenting expert,” I no longer harbored feelings of guilt or shame. This shift in perspective stems from a deeper understanding of the complexities involved.
Source: Vectorium/Shutterstock
Defining Yelling
Before delving further, it is essential to establish a clear definition of yelling. Is it synonymous with raising one’s voice after repeating instructions multiple times without a response? Is it primarily about volume, intent, or the content of the message conveyed? The discourse surrounding yelling in parenting articles lacks a consistent definition of the behavior. In behavioral science, a precise definition is crucial for meaningful analysis.
For instance, screaming differs qualitatively from yelling, often perceived as more erratic and uncontrolled. While a “scream” is typically a signal of danger, yelling can vary significantly in nature and intensity. The use of neuroscience to categorically denounce all forms of yelling, as seen in the Washington Post article, oversimplifies a complex issue. Statements like “Mom or Dad yelling at a child to take out the trash is far removed from a legitimate concern about the child’s safety if they run into the street or touch a hot stove, but the brain response is potentially the same” make bold claims without substantial evidence.
The portrayal of yelling in parenting advice seldom aligns with the reality experienced in many families, including my own and those I have worked with as a child psychologist.
The Emotional Underpinnings of Yelling
Yelling is more often an emotional reaction rather than a deliberate parenting strategy. Feelings of frustration, impatience, and overwhelm commonly trigger such responses. Few parents admit to yelling because it yields positive outcomes. Hence, attributing yelling to effective communication is misguided. Instead, the focus should shift to the emotional state of parents, who often grapple with stress and a lack of support. While children should not bear the brunt of parental stress, occasional emotional outbursts do not necessarily warrant feelings of guilt.
Contextualizing Acceptable Yelling
Asserting that yelling at children can be acceptable may seem controversial. However, certain parameters must be considered:
- The impact of the message delivered holds more significance than the volume of the voice. Verbal abuse, including insults, name-calling, or threats, is unequivocally harmful and should be avoided regardless of volume.
- The frequency of yelling is a critical factor. A pervasive atmosphere of yelling within a household signifies a lack of safety and connection, necessitating intervention. Parents who realize that yelling has become a norm in their family dynamics should address this issue promptly.
- Observing the child’s response to yelling is crucial. If a child displays signs of fear, it indicates a problem. Activating the fear center in a child’s brain through yelling triggers the fight-or-flight response, creating an undesirable environment. Recognizing such cues is imperative, prompting an immediate cessation of yelling.
The distinction lies in the fact that occasional yelling, typical in many households, differs significantly from abusive yelling that leads to lasting psychological effects. Drawing from personal experience working with abused children, I can attest to the profound impact of repeated traumatic experiences compared to sporadic outbursts in a loving parent-child relationship.
Everyone benefits from reduced yelling; therefore, advocating for occasional yelling does not imply a carte blanche for unrestrained behavior. Implementing strategies to manage emotions and prevent regrettable outbursts is advisable. While combating prevalent parental guilt, acknowledging moments of discord can serve as a catalyst for repairing and strengthening the parent-child bond.
Acknowledging Parental Background
Parents with a history of toxic yelling during their own childhood may perceive any form of yelling as threatening. This can trigger emotional flashbacks and activate the body’s fear response, necessitating a focus on the parent’s psychological well-being. Tailoring approaches to minimize yelling may be essential for individuals with such traumatic backgrounds.
Challenging the blanket notion that all forms of parental yelling are inherently harmful and must be eradicated is crucial. Such sweeping advice not only lacks nuance but may yield unintended consequences.
Embracing Emotional Authenticity
Yelling can serve as a moment of genuine emotional expression, allowing for the release of pent-up frustrations. While it should not be the sole means of emotional communication, expressing emotions openly is vital for parental well-being. Adhering to the established parameters ensures that yelling does not escalate into harmful behavior. Embracing moments of emotional release without succumbing to shame fosters healthier emotional processing and prevents uncontrolled outbursts.
Conflict, including instances of yelling, presents an opportunity for teaching and building stronger relationships with our children. Taking ownership of our reactions, connecting emotions with behavior, and reaffirming our bond through warmth and understanding can transform conflicts into valuable learning experiences. By demonstrating healthy conflict resolution within close relationships, we equip our children with essential skills for navigating challenges in their future relationships.
Resolving Conflicts
Following a tense exchange with my son, where both of us raised our voices, we later discussed the incident. As I tucked him into bed, I took responsibility for my actions and apologized. Acknowledging my feelings of tiredness and frustration, I expressed gratitude for his cooperation in maintaining our routine. This open dialogue allowed us to move past the incident without harboring any ill feelings.
In conclusion, the occasional instance of yelling, when managed within the outlined parameters, does not irreparably harm parent-child relationships. By embracing emotional authenticity, acknowledging individual backgrounds, and navigating conflicts constructively, parents can foster healthy communication and resilience in their children.